Difference between revisions of "User talk:Qwerty/Sandbox/Weapon Page"

Revision as of 03:21, 1 August 2007

• I think the board ingredients should be vertical, looks a little confusing as it is. But I dunno if that'd look much better.

Actually, looking at some other weapon pages like Blackbull, I like this setup a lot. I don't really think we need a new template, just need to put it on all weapon pages. But whatever, if we decide on a new template, I'll go with it and help out. Saiffy 00:13, 1 August 2007 (BST)

• Yeah, I'm not fond of this redesign either. In my opinion it would be better to modify the existing weapon and synth board templates so that they have a uniform appearance/design. What I like about the existing weapons template is that it automatically fills in some of the information based on the other values.
  
  It should be possible to reorganize the existing templates so that they are easier to read, while retaining their general appearance. F Gattaca 00:23, 1 August 2007 (BST)

• Personally, I think that table is ugly and confusing. Not only does the table break frequently (might not for other, I don't know), but there's just too many things all jumbled together, and too much blank space in places where it isn't needed. There's like three inches of blank space on my screen between "PP:" and the actual value of the PP. Just looks bad to me, I don't know. I think something like what I have here is just much more straightforward and orderly, though I guess a rearrangement of the current table may fix my problems with it. --Qwerty 00:46, 1 August 2007 (BST)
• The old template is broken in parts, for a start, and no-one here seems to have the knowhow to fix it. It's also somewhat complex and a pain on the eye - sites like PSOW can manage a similar layout but I don't think it's suitable for a wiki. I like this new design, it's simpler and it seems to... work with the Wiki layout, I suppose, rather than against it (I think the old layout looks horribly forced and out-of-place); but a couple of points:
  • Board stats table should be vertical. I recommend a 3x2 layout, with Ingredient 1 & 2 on the first row, 3 & 4 on the second, and the Synth Time and Base Rate on the third.
  • The gallery function is a nice way of getting multiple images of weapons. I recommend one image at the right of the page, and any other images can go in a gallery at the bottom.
  • Minor, but colour code the Rarity part of the Stats table to match the rank, using the colour values given on the Manual of Style page.
  • A grinding table, showing the stats at various grinding stages wouldn't go amiss, either. - Mewn 01:04, 1 August 2007 (BST)
    • I see. Either way, this design looks ... all over the place to me, too exploded, too random. I think I have an alternate proposal for weapon page design, if the original templates are too broken to work with. I'll try demonstrating it in my personal sandbox and make a notification about it when I'm finished. F Gattaca 01:46, 1 August 2007 (BST)

New Style

Building upon the suggestions of Mewn, I made a third variation. This variation eliminates the subheadings in favor of titled tables, and fills in some blank spaces. I put the tables themselves within a table to get them to line up real nice. In theory, the Grinding Information table could be stuck on the same line as the other three tables, but I think that would look too cluttered. Alternatively, Drop Information could be moved down a line and set before the Grinding table. Furthermore, the Gallery could be aligned directly to the left of the Grinding table, but I think that would look odd. Comments? --Qwerty 02:44, 1 August 2007 (BST)

• I like the third's board and drop info, with the first's item stats and item description layout. :S --Beatrixkiddo 04:21, 1 August 2007 (BST)