Talk:Spread Needle/G - Revision history

AngelusInsomnus at 18:12, 26 May 2009

2009-05-26T18:12:12Z

Punisher106 at 04:38, 31 March 2009

2009-03-31T04:38:55Z

Mewn at 17:34, 10 May 2008

2008-05-10T17:34:40Z

Sekani at 15:56, 10 May 2008

2008-05-10T15:56:55Z

TheRandomHunter: New page: Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really ...

2008-05-10T10:04:02Z

New page: Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really ...

New page

Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really conform to either Rifle or Shotgun? [[User:TheRandomHunter|TheRandomHunter]] 06:03, May 10 2008

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:12, 26 May 2009
Line 3:		Line 3:
	* Spread Needle was neither a Shotgun nor a Rifle, it was a unique class of weapon. But I'm tempted to agree that to debate this would be over-technical, and giving it the Shotgun moniker does make it nice and simple for people who never played PSU and wouldn't necessarily know exactly what a Needle meant. It's worth pointing out that the Spread Needle description on PSO calls it 'a custom shotgun.' - [[User:Mewn\|Mewn]] 12:34, 10 May 2008 (CDT)		* Spread Needle was neither a Shotgun nor a Rifle, it was a unique class of weapon. But I'm tempted to agree that to debate this would be over-technical, and giving it the Shotgun moniker does make it nice and simple for people who never played PSU and wouldn't necessarily know exactly what a Needle meant. It's worth pointing out that the Spread Needle description on PSO calls it 'a custom shotgun.' - [[User:Mewn\|Mewn]] 12:34, 10 May 2008 (CDT)
	* I actually agree. It should be listed as a sort of a rifle, since it has the rifle-type power, except for the fact that you can hit five enemies. [[User:Punisher106\|Punisher106]] 23:38, 30 March 2009 (CDT)		* I actually agree. It should be listed as a sort of a rifle, since it has the rifle-type power, except for the fact that you can hit five enemies. [[User:Punisher106\|Punisher106]] 23:38, 30 March 2009 (CDT)
		+	* Compromise: don't call it either. Just say, "a weapon from Phantasy Star Online" --[[User:AngelusInsomnus\|AngelusInsomnus]] 13:12, 26 May 2009 (CDT)

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:38, 31 March 2009
Line 2:		Line 2:
	* That's getting a little over-technical in my opinion. Besides, anyone who didn't play PSO wouldn't understand the distinction, and explaining it would be beyond the scope of this wiki. For descriptive purposes, the Spread Needle was a shotgun--an unusual one as far as animations, firing rate, and equip requirements went, but still a shotgun. - [[User:Sekani\|Sekani]] 10:56, 10 May 2008 (CDT)		* That's getting a little over-technical in my opinion. Besides, anyone who didn't play PSO wouldn't understand the distinction, and explaining it would be beyond the scope of this wiki. For descriptive purposes, the Spread Needle was a shotgun--an unusual one as far as animations, firing rate, and equip requirements went, but still a shotgun. - [[User:Sekani\|Sekani]] 10:56, 10 May 2008 (CDT)
	* Spread Needle was neither a Shotgun nor a Rifle, it was a unique class of weapon. But I'm tempted to agree that to debate this would be over-technical, and giving it the Shotgun moniker does make it nice and simple for people who never played PSU and wouldn't necessarily know exactly what a Needle meant. It's worth pointing out that the Spread Needle description on PSO calls it 'a custom shotgun.' - [[User:Mewn\|Mewn]] 12:34, 10 May 2008 (CDT)		* Spread Needle was neither a Shotgun nor a Rifle, it was a unique class of weapon. But I'm tempted to agree that to debate this would be over-technical, and giving it the Shotgun moniker does make it nice and simple for people who never played PSU and wouldn't necessarily know exactly what a Needle meant. It's worth pointing out that the Spread Needle description on PSO calls it 'a custom shotgun.' - [[User:Mewn\|Mewn]] 12:34, 10 May 2008 (CDT)
		+	* I actually agree. It should be listed as a sort of a rifle, since it has the rifle-type power, except for the fact that you can hit five enemies. [[User:Punisher106\|Punisher106]] 23:38, 30 March 2009 (CDT)

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:34, 10 May 2008
Line 1:		Line 1:
	Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really conform to either Rifle or Shotgun? [[User:TheRandomHunter\|TheRandomHunter]] 06:03, May 10 2008		Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really conform to either Rifle or Shotgun? [[User:TheRandomHunter\|TheRandomHunter]] 06:03, May 10 2008
	* That's getting a little over-technical in my opinion. Besides, anyone who didn't play PSO wouldn't understand the distinction, and explaining it would be beyond the scope of this wiki. For descriptive purposes, the Spread Needle was a shotgun--an unusual one as far as animations, firing rate, and equip requirements went, but still a shotgun. - [[User:Sekani\|Sekani]] 10:56, 10 May 2008 (CDT)		* That's getting a little over-technical in my opinion. Besides, anyone who didn't play PSO wouldn't understand the distinction, and explaining it would be beyond the scope of this wiki. For descriptive purposes, the Spread Needle was a shotgun--an unusual one as far as animations, firing rate, and equip requirements went, but still a shotgun. - [[User:Sekani\|Sekani]] 10:56, 10 May 2008 (CDT)
		+	* Spread Needle was neither a Shotgun nor a Rifle, it was a unique class of weapon. But I'm tempted to agree that to debate this would be over-technical, and giving it the Shotgun moniker does make it nice and simple for people who never played PSU and wouldn't necessarily know exactly what a Needle meant. It's worth pointing out that the Spread Needle description on PSO calls it 'a custom shotgun.' - [[User:Mewn\|Mewn]] 12:34, 10 May 2008 (CDT)

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:56, 10 May 2008
Line 1:		Line 1:
	Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really conform to either Rifle or Shotgun? [[User:TheRandomHunter\|TheRandomHunter]] 06:03, May 10 2008		Is that part about it being a "shotgun" on PSO technically right? I mean, it had a Rifle animation and Rifle speed. Shouldn't it say it was a unique type of weapon, since it didn't really conform to either Rifle or Shotgun? [[User:TheRandomHunter\|TheRandomHunter]] 06:03, May 10 2008
		+	* That's getting a little over-technical in my opinion. Besides, anyone who didn't play PSO wouldn't understand the distinction, and explaining it would be beyond the scope of this wiki. For descriptive purposes, the Spread Needle was a shotgun--an unusual one as far as animations, firing rate, and equip requirements went, but still a shotgun. - [[User:Sekani\|Sekani]] 10:56, 10 May 2008 (CDT)